7/24 Service · Chinese / English

China Patent Invalidation and Administrative Proceedings: A Defense Guide for Foreign Companies

You do not challenge a Chinese patent by suing in court first. Under Articles 45 and 46 of the Patent Law, invalidation is an administrative request to the CNIPA, followed by judicial review in the Beijing Intellectual Property Court — and the distinction decides your whole strategy.

China Patent Invalidation and Administrative Proceedings: A Defense Guide for Foreign Companies

The invalidation route is administrative, not a court lawsuit

The first thing a foreign company learns about challenging a Chinese patent is that you do not start in court. Under the current Patent Law (fourth amendment, effective 1 June 2021), Article 45 lets any person — a competitor, a customer, or anyone with standing to care — request that the State Council's patent administrative department, in practice the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA), declare a patent invalid. Article 46 requires CNIPA to examine the request and issue a decision, and gives a party dissatisfied with the decision three months from receipt to sue in court. The point is structural: invalidation is an administrative procedure first, with judicial review afterwards.

The grounds: what actually invalidates a patent

The grounds mirror the grant conditions. Article 22 sets novelty, inventiveness and practical applicability for inventions and utility models — "prior art" being anything known to the public at home or abroad before the filing date. Article 23 requires a design to differ distinctly from prior designs and not conflict with earlier lawful rights. Article 26(3) is the disclosure ground: the description must set out the invention clearly and completely enough for a person skilled in the art to carry it out. Article 20, added in the 2020 amendment, requires that patent applications and the exercise of patent rights follow the principle of good faith, and is now an independent ground worth pleading where the patent was obtained or asserted abusively. In practice, novelty and inventiveness under Article 22 and insufficiency under Article 26(3) carry most invalidation requests.

The two-step administrative–judicial structure

The invalidation request is examined by CNIPA's Re-examination and Invalidation Department. If a party is dissatisfied with the decision, the administrative lawsuit is filed in the Beijing Intellectual Property Court as the first instance, with CNIPA as the defendant, and any appeal goes to the Intellectual Property Tribunal of the Supreme People's Court, which has centralised jurisdiction over technical IP administrative appeals. Two practical consequences follow. First, the court reviews the legality of CNIPA's decision rather than re-deciding validity itself — it may set the decision aside and remit, but it does not simply rewrite the patent. Second, the losing party in an infringement suit will often run the invalidation route in parallel to delay or collapse the infringement case, so timing the two proceedings together is half the strategy.

Strategy for a foreign company

  1. Run the prior-art search before you commit: an invalidation request is only as good as the prior-art and disclosure evidence behind it, and CNIPA will not do the search for you.
  2. Coordinate with the infringement action: a stay of the infringement suit pending invalidation is discretionary, so show the court a credible, well-evidenced request rather than a fishing expedition.
  3. Watch the three-month appeal window under Article 46 — it is short and runs from receipt of the CNIPA decision.
  4. Use the request as leverage: for a foreign company hit with an assertion from a weak patent, a serious invalidation filing is often the fastest route to a settlement on reasonable terms.

— Danny Luo, Attorney-at-law, Tianni Law Firm, Nanjing. This article is provided for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

This article is provided by Tianni Law Firm for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice on a specific matter, please contact a qualified attorney.

Challenge or defend a Chinese patent.

We run invalidation requests before the CNIPA and coordinate them with infringement proceedings for foreign companies across the technology and industrial sectors.

Related Articles