7/24 Service · Chinese / English

China Foreign Investment Law: National Treatment, Negative List and Dispute Resolution for Foreign Investors

China's Foreign Investment Law, effective 1 January 2020, replaced the Sino-Foreign Equity Joint Ventures Law, the Sino-Foreign Cooperative Joint Ventures Law and the Wholly Foreign-Owned Enterprises Law with one uniform regime. Its core is pre-establishment national treatment plus a negative list — and its definition of foreign investment is broad enough to catch structures an investor might assume are outside it.

China Foreign Investment Law: National Treatment, Negative List and Dispute Resolution for Foreign Investors

The law that replaced three laws

On 1 January 2020, China's Foreign Investment Law (外商投资法) took effect and replaced, in a single statute, the three laws that had governed foreign-invested enterprises for four decades — the Sino-Foreign Equity Joint Ventures Law, the Sino-Foreign Cooperative Joint Ventures Law and the Wholly Foreign-Owned Enterprises Law. The change is more than consolidation. The old regime was approval-driven and entity-specific; the new law is a single, uniform regime built around two concepts: pre-establishment national treatment and a negative list. For a foreign investor structuring a China entry, this is the statute that sets the ground rules on what you may own, how you are treated, and how you resolve a dispute with the state.

Pre-establishment national treatment and the negative list

The core promise of the Foreign Investment Law is that foreign investors receive treatment no less favourable than domestic investors, and that this treatment applies at the pre-establishment stage — before you set up — not just after you are in. The mechanism is the negative list (外商投资准入负面清单), which lists the sectors where foreign investment is restricted or prohibited; everything off the list is open. Where an item is restricted, the investor typically faces an equity cap, a qualified controlling shareholding requirement, or a joint-venture requirement. The list is updated regularly and has been shortened over successive versions, but the restricted sectors — media, certain telecoms, and a handful of others — remain genuinely restricted. The practical rule is simple: check the current negative list first, because a sector that looks open can carry a residual restriction buried in a later version of the list.

What counts as foreign investment

The law defines foreign investment broadly to capture four forms: (1) establishing a foreign-invested enterprise in China; (2) acquiring shares, equity or other similar rights in a Chinese enterprise; (3) investing in a new project jointly or alone; and (4) other investment forms prescribed by law or the State Council. The breadth matters because it sweeps in structures — a merger, an asset purchase, a VIE-style arrangement, a loan that is really equity — that an investor might otherwise treat as outside the regime. The definition, not the label, decides whether the transaction is foreign investment subject to the information-reporting and negative-list rules.

Protection: expropriation, remittance and intellectual property

The law contains the protections a foreign investor most often asks about. It provides that the state will not expropriate foreign investment except in the public interest and in accordance with legal procedures, with fair and reasonable compensation. It guarantees the freedom to remit profits, capital gains, royalties and other income abroad in accordance with the law — subject, in practice, to the tax and foreign-exchange rules that apply to any cross-border payment. It also commits to protecting foreign investors' intellectual property and to prohibiting forced technology transfer, a provision aimed squarely at a long-running complaint of foreign businesses. These are statutory protections, but they operate within the ordinary rules on tax, foreign exchange and licensing, so the protection is as good as the surrounding compliance.

Information reporting instead of approval

For sectors outside the negative list, the approval regime is gone. In its place is an information-reporting system: the investor reports the establishment and changes of the enterprise to the commerce authority through the enterprise registration system, and the reports feed into a national system shared with market regulation, foreign exchange and other agencies. Reporting is lighter than approval, but it is not optional, and a failure to report, or a false report, can draw administrative sanctions. The operational consequence is that "no approval needed" does not mean "nothing to file" — the filing obligations continue through the life of the investment.

Resolving disputes with the state and with partners

The Foreign Investment Law's own dispute machinery is administrative, not arbitral. Article 26 provides that the state establishes a complaint-and-coordination mechanism for foreign-invested enterprises, and that where an investor considers that an administrative act infringes its legitimate rights and interests, it may resolve the matter through the complaint mechanism and, in accordance with the law, apply for administrative reconsideration or bring administrative litigation. Disputes between a foreign investor and a private counterparty — a joint-venture partner, a seller, a buyer — are not resolved by the Foreign Investment Law itself; they are governed by the ordinary rules of contract and company law, and by the parties' agreement. Arbitration in such disputes is a matter of voluntary choice under the Arbitration Law or an applicable investment treaty, not a remedy the Foreign Investment Law confers. For an investor, the drafting point is the same as in any China deal: choose the forum and the governing rules expressly, because silence on dispute resolution in a China contract is a decision made by default rather than by design.

For foreign investors, the Foreign Investment Law is the entry point to the whole China regime: national treatment subject to a negative list, a broad definition of what is caught, statutory protections that operate within the ordinary tax and foreign-exchange rules, and a reporting system that has replaced approval without abolishing the duty to file. Read the current negative list first, and draft the dispute clause deliberately.

— Danny Luo, Attorney-at-law, Tianni Law Firm, Nanjing. This article is provided for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

This article is provided by Tianni Law Firm for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice on a specific matter, please contact a qualified attorney.

Structure a China investment that holds up under the Foreign Investment Law.

We advise foreign investors on market access under the current negative list, transaction structure, information reporting and dispute-resolution strategy in China.

Related Articles