7/24 Service · Chinese / English

China ESG and Greenwashing Claims: Litigation and Regulatory Defense for Foreign Companies

A 'carbon neutral' label, a 'zero-carbon' product line or a '100% recyclable' claim is marketing until a regulator or a competitor treats it as a false or misleading commercial statement. In China that line now sits in Article 9 of the 2025 Anti-Unfair Competition Law — and the article number matters, because Article 8 is now commercial bribery.

China ESG and Greenwashing Claims: Litigation and Regulatory Defense for Foreign Companies

No standalone anti-greenwashing law — the risk is assembled from three statutes

China has no single "anti-greenwashing" statute and no dedicated enforcement basis for green claims. A company that says its product is "carbon neutral", "zero-carbon", "100% recyclable" or "fully degradable" is therefore exposed not to one law but to three, each enforced by the State Administration for Market Regulation and the local market regulators: the Anti-Unfair Competition Law, the Advertising Law and the Consumer Rights Protection Law. The claim becomes a case when it is false or misleading — and in 2025 the key article number changed, which is the most common drafting mistake we see in compliance memos.

The 2025 Anti-Unfair Competition Law: false or misleading commercial publicity is now Article 9

The Anti-Unfair Competition Law was revised for the second time on 27 June 2025 and took effect on 15 October 2025. After the revision, false or misleading commercial publicity sits in Article 9, not the old Article 8. Article 9 prohibits an operator from making false or misleading statements about the performance, function, quality, sales status, user reviews or honours of its goods, and it now also prohibits organising false transactions or false reviews to help another operator. The penalty for violation is in Article 25: a fine of up to RMB 1 million, or RMB 1–2 million in serious cases, together with possible revocation of the business licence. A point worth underlining: after the 2025 revision, commercial bribery is Article 8 — so any internal memo that still cites "Article 8" for publicity claims is citing the bribery article by mistake.

The Advertising Law: absolute terms and false advertising

Green claims that run in advertising are also caught by the Advertising Law. Article 9(3) prohibits "national-level", "top-grade", "best" and similar absolute terms, and Article 28 defines false advertising as advertising that deceives or misleads consumers with false or misleading content. A sustainability claim that uses an unverifiable research finding, statistic or survey as supporting material falls squarely within Article 28. The practical rule is that "best-in-class low-carbon", "the most sustainable" and similar superlatives are drafted as violations, not as marketing style.

Consumer Protection Law: the general duty and punitive damages

The Consumer Rights Protection Law adds the general duty. Article 20 requires an operator to provide true and comprehensive information about the quality, performance, use and useful life of its goods and services, and not to make false or misleading statements. Where a misleading green claim induces a consumer to buy, Article 55 exposes the seller to punitive damages of three times the price, and Article 45 lets an injured consumer claim against the operator for loss caused by false advertising or publicity. The consumer route is the one that turns a regulatory fine into a class-style series of individual claims.

The exchanges' sustainability-reporting rules and their limits

On the disclosure side, the SSE, SZSE and BSE issued the Guidelines for Sustainability Reports of Listed Companies on 12 April 2024, effective 1 May 2024. Mandatory disclosure applies to companies continuously included in the SSE 180, STAR 50, SZSE 100 and ChiNext indices, and to companies listed both domestically and overseas, with the first mandatory disclosure of the 2025 financial year due by 30 April 2026. Those guidelines are self-regulatory exchange rules, not statute: a failure to disclose, or a misleading disclosure, triggers exchange self-regulatory measures first, and only becomes a securities false-statement problem if the disclosure also falls within the securities-law information-disclosure duty — a boundary that is still contested, so the safe drafting is "subject to the latest official guidance". The exchange guidelines do not themselves create a greenwashing offence.

How to defend a green claim

  1. Substantiate before you publish: keep the test report, certification and methodology behind every "carbon neutral", "zero-carbon" or "recyclable" claim, because Article 28 turns an unverifiable claim into false advertising.
  2. Remove absolute terms: strip "best", "first", "most" and "100%" unless the 100% is literally and provably true.
  3. Align the ESG report with the evidence: the exchanges' guidelines reward verifiable indicators, and an overstated metric is the first document a regulator or competitor will quote against you.
  4. If the market regulator opens an investigation, respond early with the evidence file and, where appropriate, a correction or withdrawal of the claim — the Article 25 penalty and the Article 55 consumer claims both get worse the longer the claim stays up uncorrected.

— Danny Luo, Attorney-at-law, Tianni Law Firm, Nanjing. This article is provided for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

This article is provided by Tianni Law Firm for general information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice on a specific matter, please contact a qualified attorney.

Defend or prevent a greenwashing claim in China.

We advise foreign companies on substantiating sustainability claims, responding to market-regulator investigations and aligning ESG disclosure with the evidence.

Related Articles